Skip to content

Innovation

This analysis estimates whether firm-wide match quality predicts subsequent issued-patent counts and quality. Zero-inclusive Poisson pseudo-maximum likelihood (PPML) is used for patent counts. OLS is used for real value and citations per issued patent, conditional on a positive cumulative issued-patent count.

Inputs
Dataset Location Grain
Full-training Compustat--CRSP MQ panel /data//analyses/full_training/compustat_crsp_mq.parquet GVKEY--fiscal year
Time-profile Compustat--CRSP MQ panel /data//analyses/profile_time/training/compustat_crsp_mq.parquet GVKEY--fiscal year and sample status

One run attempts three samples: full-training in-sample, time-profile in-sample (sample_status == "in_sample"), and time-profile out-of-sample (sample_status == "out_of_sample"). Each writes to a separate output folder. If an input dataset is unavailable, that sample is logged and skipped while the others can still run.

Build
Component Location
Shared panel construction analyses/modules/firm_mq_innovation.R
Regression and table module analyses/modules/firm_mq_innovation_analysis.R
Pipeline entry point analyses/pipelines/run_firm_mq_innovation.R
Runtime hct-tower-analyses-cpu
Output

The pipeline writes the same seventeen-table set for each available sample. Full-training outputs remain in the existing directory; time-profile results are under time_in_sample/ and time_out_of_sample/.

Table Location
Sample construction and stock-group shares /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_sample_construction.tex
Issued-patent t+5, full sample /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_t5_full_sample.tex
Issued-patent t+5, top-stock and bottom-stock groups /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_t5_top10_bottom90.tex
Full-sample horizons, industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_horizons_industry_year.tex
Full-sample horizons, firm plus industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_horizons_firm_industry_year.tex
Top-stock horizons, industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_horizons_top10_industry_year.tex
Bottom-stock horizons, industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_horizons_bottom90_industry_year.tex
Top-stock horizons, firm plus industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_horizons_top10_firm_industry_year.tex
Bottom-stock horizons, firm plus industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_horizons_bottom90_firm_industry_year.tex
Log-count t+5 robustness /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_log_t5_full_sample.tex
Log-count horizons, industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_log_horizons_industry_year.tex
Log-count horizons, firm plus industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_log_horizons_firm_industry_year.tex
Log-count t+5, top-stock and bottom-stock groups /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_log_t5_top10_bottom90.tex
Top-stock log-count horizons, industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_log_horizons_top10_industry_year.tex
Bottom-stock log-count horizons, industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_log_horizons_bottom90_industry_year.tex
Top-stock log-count horizons, firm plus industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_log_horizons_top10_firm_industry_year.tex
Bottom-stock log-count horizons, firm plus industry-by-year FE /artifacts//analyses/firm_mq_innovation/firm_mq_innovation_log_horizons_bottom90_firm_industry_year.tex

The time-profile in-sample run also writes two fixed-2016-baseline tables in /artifacts/<coverage>/analyses/firm_mq_innovation/time_in_sample/: firm_mq_innovation_2016_baseline_controls_only.tex and firm_mq_innovation_2016_baseline_industry_fe.tex.

Specification

All regressions use issued-patent outcomes. The t+5 table reports cumulative patents issued, real value per issued patent, and citations per issued patent for three specifications: controls plus industry and year fixed effects, industry-by-year fixed effects, and firm plus industry-by-year fixed effects. The t+5 stock-split table presents those same specifications for the high-stock group in columns 1--3 and the low-stock group in columns 4--6. Horizon tables report t+1 through t+5 results for the two industry-based FE structures, with separate high- and low-stock tables as robustness checks.

The high/low split is assigned once per MQ-qualified firm-year using trailing three-year issued-patent stock. The 90th-percentile cutoff is calculated on MQ-qualified firm-years with observed stock before requiring forward outcomes. Ties at the cutoff stay together in the high-stock group; the sample table reports realized group shares. The log robustness uses OLS for winsorized log(1 + cumulative patents issued) and mirrors the t+5 and horizon specifications in the full sample and top/bottom stock groups.

Every outcome, the focal Firm MQ measure, Firm MQ SD, and other continuous controls are winsorized at the 1st and 99th percentiles within each full-sample complete-case regression sample before splitting by stock group. The same outcome and continuous-variable winsorization limits are used for both groups. Prior issued-patent stock enters every regression as the winsorized log(1 + stock) control. Generated tables display the Firm MQ and Firm MQ SD coefficients with standard errors. Standard errors are clustered by GVKEY.

The data preparation continues to construct both filed- and issued-patent lagged stocks, but filed-patent outcomes are not estimated. The minimum MQ-score threshold defaults to 20 scored relationships per firm-year.

MQ baseline years are not capped at 2023. Patent outcomes are complete only through 2024, so eligible baseline years vary by horizon: t+1 through 2023, t+2 through 2022, and so on, with t+5 through 2019. Complete-case filtering applies these horizon limits separately to each regression.

The additional fixed-baseline specification uses the time-profile in-sample firm-year for 2016 as the sole source of Firm MQ and control variables, then relates those values to cumulative issued-patent outcomes beginning in 2017. Its five columns cover t+1 (2017) through t+5 (2021); each table reports the existing three outcomes (issued counts, citations per patent, and real value per patent). The two specifications are controls only and NAICS 3-digit industry fixed effects. Firm fixed effects are not identified in a one-year cross-section. The regular full-training and time-profile tables remain unchanged.

Command reference
Argument Required / default Effect
config.yaml Required positional argument Analyses YAML config. Use analyses/config/config_full.yaml for full-sample output paths.
minimum_mq_scores 20 in the analysis function Minimum scored relationships per firm-year; not a CLI option.

Use the firm-mq-innovation task for the current pipeline.

cd /hct-tower/analyses
Rscript --vanilla pipelines/run_firm_mq_innovation.R \
  config/config_full.yaml
cd /hct-tower
slurm/submit.sh --task firm-mq-innovation --config config_full.yaml

The pipeline writes timestamped progress to standard output, including input loading, stock-group shares, model fits, and table writes. It refits the models when run and does not expose a --rerun flag.